Infendo’s Top 10 Mario Games
Saturday, June 28th, 2008 at 1:40pm by Derek
[In honor of the Super Mario Marathon, we re-publish our Top 10 Mario Games list!]
Now that we’ve had some time to digest his latest adventure, the Infendo offices have been buzzing with debate. It spilled over into last week’s edition of Infendo Radio and has since been the subject of countless e-mails from listeners, readers and tipsters all week long:
Which Mario games stand the test of time? Which are the cream?
We’ve set some parameters for debate, and the qualifying criteria for a “Mario game” were fairly rigid during the development of this list. We avoided including entries from the countless Mario spin-off franchises, such as Mario Kart and Mario Party, with one obvious and deserving exception. We are referring to proper Mario platformers.
After all, this is serious business. Place your bets, friends.
10. Super Mario RPG
Mario purists could justifiably scoff at our inclusion of Square’s 1996 SNES masterpiece, Super Mario RPG.
I certainly concede that Super Mario RPG is anything but a proper Mario game. Still, there is something to be said for unabashed merriment, and at its most basic purpose, any serious best-of list should pay reverence to relentless, unfaltering awesomeness.
And incidentally, Super Mario RPG is both relentlessly awesome and bursting with irresistible merriment. The spiritual predecessor of the Paper Mario series, Super Mario RPG successfully marked Mario’s first foray into the world of role-playing games. In addition to pushing the SNES to produce the most beautiful simulated 3D graphics this side of Donkey Kong Country, Super Mario RPG also proved the versatility of the character; whether platforming, kart racing or, as Square proved, teaming up with Bowser for turn-based battles, it seemed there was almost no genre in which Mario couldn’t excel.
9. Super Mario Land 2
Given his absurd ability to drive console sales, Nintendo wanted to release a five-star Mario exclusive alongside the Game Boy in 1989. Enter the original Super Mario Land, which sold more than 18 million copies and stands as the third best-selling Mario game of all time.
And one of the worst. Don’t be fooled by nostalgia; the game is lousy.
Fortunately, Gunpei Yokoi’s Super Mario Land 2 was a monumental improvement over his original, perhaps most obviously in terms of its aesthetic refinement. Mario was plump and jovial, a monochromatic clone of his SNES model, and enemies were large and detailed, rendering the awkward animations and microscopic sprites of the original even less appealing. The sequel also gained enjoyability from the introduction of Wario, far more compelling a villain and more memorable a character than the original’s Tatanga, as time has proven. Super Mario Land 2 was everything a sequel to a sub-par game should be: good enough to render the first forgivable.
8. Super Mario Bros. 2
The original Super Mario Bros. had made Nintendo a household name across the globe. Even then, before “sequelitis” came to define the industry, Nintendo was eager to deliver more Mario to the masses.
Nintendo released Super Mario Bros. 2 in Japan less than nine months after the original. However, the company feared the sequel was too similar to the original and difficult beyond necessity. Afraid it would harm Mario’s popularity among Western audiences, Nintendo reworked 1987’s Doki Doki Panic into the oddball adventure we’ve come to know as Super Mario Bros. 2.
Given its characters were merely masked with Mario sprites, the vegetable-tossing premise seems obtrusive within the context of the Mario canon. But it introduced several characters that have since become Mario staples, including Shy Guy and the egg-spitting Birdo, while the platform-heavy gameplay had enough in common with the original to make the sequel a convincing, competent Mario title. Ironically, it has since transcended its original form to become one of Mario’s most beloved and inexplicably addictive adventures.
7. New Super Mario Bros.
There is no better example of “right place, right time” than 2006’s DS masterpiece, New Super Mario Bros.
Long after Mario’s groundbreaking leap into three dimensions, it had been 15 excruciatingly long years since Nintendo released an original, side-scrolling 2D Mario platformer. As the 13 million who bought the game can attest, it was worth the wait.
The plot is all-too-familiar: Bowser kidnaps the Princess, chase ensues. The moves hadn’t changed, almost becoming second-nature for seasoned players: jump, run, jump, warp, flag pole. Even the faces are the same: Goomba, Koopa Troopa, Blooper, Luigi. But trendy obligatory demands for innovation aside, these familiarities are precisely what make New Super Mario Bros. so damn special. Though a throwback to simpler times, it also happens to be one of the most beautiful and polished DS games ever made. Inspiring to play and impossible to put down, it shines amidst hooker-beatings and sniper-deaths to prove that the best video games are still about fun.
6. Super Mario Sunshine
I have always worn my adoration for Super Mario Sunshine boldly on my sleeve. My very first article for Infendo, in fact, was a gushing love letter detailing why it is “the greatest Mario game you’ve ever hated.”
Sunshine will always hold a special place in my heart, and to be honest, it has less to do with nostalgia than with how truly spectacular it is.
Controlling Mario through Isle Delfino was a revelation, as Nintendo refined Mario’s controls to perfection in Sunshine. Refinements were also abound in the visual department; from sparkling beaches to grassy mountain villages, playing Sunshine was like watching art in motion, offering one of Mario’s most visually appealing landscapes.
In terms of platforming, few Mario games can rival the ease of control and perplexity of challenge prevalent in Sunshine. The FLUDD waterpack gave Mario more diverse and satisfying moves than ever before; from towering sections of Noki Bay and Bianco Hills to the challenge of the secret stages, each Isle Delfino locale was a joy to explore. Sorry haters; the problem was with you, not Sunshine.
5. Super Mario Bros.
What can be said about a game with a theme song that has done more for gaming than most other games have done in their entirety?
I wouldn’t be writing about video games had I not received Super Mario Bros. for my fourth birthday. I’d also be willing to wager most of us wouldn’t even be playing games if not for Miyamoto’s original masterpiece.
As undemanding as the gameplay may seem, it is deceptively deep and grants players unique possibilities. The 32 levels and eight worlds of Super Mario Bros. also made the game uncharacteristically epic for its time; Mario’s journey through the Mushroom Kingdom spanned daylight and nightfall, grassy flats and subterranean caverns, enemy-filled oceans and mushroom-top heavens.
Super Mario Bros. is timeless. It survives not only because of nostalgia, but because of how immaculately well-designed it is. The level design is still consistently impressive; each flows perfectly into the next. The gameplay is as precise and responsive today as it was 20 years ago. The characters are still charming and lovable, and most impressively, have permeated our culture and given rise to one of its most beloved fictional worlds. After all…you’re here, right?
4. Super Mario 64
You know you’re playing something special when the very first scene becomes etched into your memory.
Perhaps even more iconic than the first screen in Super Mario Bros. and the epic camera pan of Kokiri Forest in Ocarina of Time is the opening scene of Super Mario 64, when Mario first appears in stunning 3D. We all remember, and we’ll never forget.
Because in gaming circles, images simply do not come any more memorable. The instantly impressive opening area of Super Mario 64 set the stage for what many gamers maintain is the greatest game of all time. Hell, simply exploring these initial Castle grounds was enough entertainment for some. My sister would climb trees, swim through the moat and launch Mario gleefully through the air for hours, it seemed, without so much as entering the castle.
Had she progressed enough to experience the complexities of masterfully designed levels like Tick Tock Clock, Whomp’s Fortress and Rainbow Ride, her head might’ve exploded.
3. Super Mario World
Some minor objections have been raised to my placement of Super Mario World above Super Mario 64. So before praising the SNES classic, brief justification is in order:
Super Mario World has even better level design, even better progression and is even more fun than the Nintendo 64 magnum opus. Don’t blame me; blame Yoshi.
This game has aged remarkably well, a statement which cannot be applied as confidently to Super Mario 64. The innovative level design prevalent throughout the game is as refreshing today as ever; from the simple Donut Plains through the perplexing Forest of Illusion and into Chocolate Island, each cleverly designed world is a treat to play through. Along with multiple objectives within levels, infallible stage design and progression, new power-ups and countless secret areas, Super Mario World gives Mario a cape. That seals the deal, for me.
2. Super Mario Galaxy
It hasn’t been out long, but 15 minutes with Super Mario Galaxy is enough to prove its classic merit.
Upon arriving in the Good Egg Galaxy, I knew I was playing something special. But once I hit the Honeyhive Galaxy, my giddy enthusiasm bubbled over into pure astonishment at first-sight of the Bee Suit. After twenty years of Mario games in which we thought we’d seen it all, Nintendo somehow found a way to surprise us, to reach that inner child who was just as thrilled to first discover the Raccoon Leaf, Feather Cape and Fire Flower all those dusty decades ago.
By the time I reached the final confrontation with Bowser, I had experienced more in a single Mario game than any prior could offer: an incredible musical score, masterful gameplay mechanics, fun level design and more imagination than any game I’d ever played, for starters. Not only is it the most goosebump-inducingly epic Mario game of all time, but Super Mario Galaxy is also the most beautiful Nintendo game ever. They cannot possibly outdo this one, can they?
1. Super Mario Bros. 3
I’ve been watching the Rocky films epics a lot lately, and I’ve learned something very important.
Sometimes, it just comes down to heart; who has done it the best, and who wants it more? So sure, Clubber Lang and Ivan Drago were younger, fresher, lethal and more toned. Big deal. Rocky had freakin’ heart.
This game is kinda like Rocky.
After all, Mario and Rocky are both Italian stallions. And in Super Mario Bros. 3, Mario pulled a Rocky; he just did it right. Prettier, faster and bigger challengers to the throne have come and gone, yet this game stands, battle hardened and proudly showing its scars, as the definitive Mario experience. The premise was familiar; eight worlds, countless levels, run and jump, save the Princess. But never before had it been as fully realized as it had with Super Mario Bros. 3. While other Mario games have edged by it in specific areas, none have been able to match its overall excellence and classic feel. When someone asks what Mario is all about, slap them and hand them a cartridge copy of Super Mario Bros. 3.
Agree? Disagree? Share your own list in the comments.
April 9th, 2008 at 7:22 am
Hmmm. The list is pretty good. Scott will be mad that SMB64 was #4 though
April 9th, 2008 at 8:22 am
no paper marios?? Yeah I think Mario 64 could have been up to at least #2… I didn’t like galaxy. But come on Paper Mario should be on there…. I mean mario RPG is…
April 9th, 2008 at 8:36 am
@nintenmania
Yeah, Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door was one of my favorite game ever!! That game was amazing!! Paper Mario is just an awesome idea
April 9th, 2008 at 10:47 am
Also must mention Paper Mario, espeically the Thousend Year Door. Loved that game. But ranking Mario games is an exercise in futility. They are all so good.
Glad Sunshine was not left off this list. Many argue the tropical island setting did not feel like a Mario game, but the setting sets it apart from the usual ice/lava/water worlds that have become so cliche. Isle Delfino is a place I would like to visit. The amusement park level was especially awesome, despite the tedious trek up the back of the Ferris Wheel.
April 9th, 2008 at 11:15 am
Yayyyyy. SMB3!
I think this list is pretty good, though New SMB was great but wasn’t anything special to me.
April 9th, 2008 at 11:29 am
I have to disagree with Sunshine being as high as #6. If anything that game would barely break my Top 10. I would have put Paper Mario: TTYD before it. The rest I don’t have much of a problem with.
April 9th, 2008 at 11:43 am
About Paper Mario titles. From the article:
“We avoided including entries from the countless Mario spin-off franchises, such as Mario Kart and Mario Party, with one obvious and deserving exception. We are referring to proper Mario platformers.”
The Mario RPG series was excluded from the list; that one “obvious and deserving exception” is, obviously, Super Mario RPG. I feel it is a better, more groundbreaking game than its spiritual successors, which might not even exist if not for it.
April 9th, 2008 at 12:48 pm
Derek writes: “I’d also be willing to wager most of us wouldn’t even be playing games if not for Miyamoto’s original masterpiece.”
I suppose that might apply to you youngsters, but us older farts had well established our videogame addictions long before this game was nothing more than just a twinkle in the eye of Miyamoto (in fact my gaming goes back even before Mario made his first appearance in the original Donkey Kong).
I can’t say that I agree with all the selections, and/or their order of ranking, but like someone else said, trying to rank Mario games can be nothing more than a work of futility. What’s the favorite game of one person, can be the least favorite of another. But I think that there is one thing that most of us can agree on - Mario Rocks.
April 9th, 2008 at 12:51 pm
Bottom line, if you’re going to include Super Mario RPG, then the PM games are fair game for discussion, regardless of your disclaimers to the contrary. You made an exception for SMRPG, fine; I’m making one for PM:TTYD.
April 9th, 2008 at 1:53 pm
Great list, Derek!
Only difference would be Super Mario World at number 1 (Who can’t resist Yoshi).
This puts a lot of pressure on my top ten Zelda games list next week. Better put some ddep thought into it.
April 9th, 2008 at 1:57 pm
I’d put one of the Paper Mario titles on there and take off Mario 2. Just my opinion.
April 9th, 2008 at 4:03 pm
NSMB didn’t have enough soul for me, I think its too early to make that call on Galaxy, and I still believe World to be far superior to 3.
But that’s just me.
April 9th, 2008 at 4:22 pm
I actually think super mario sunshine should be higher.But who knows,maybe I don’t like the old games because I’m a kid.Planning to get super mario 64 with some Wii points as soon as I get the money.
April 9th, 2008 at 6:07 pm
Now give me the “Top 10 Mario Games, No Platformers Edition” with some Kart and Paper Mario in it.
April 9th, 2008 at 6:33 pm
I feel that Mario RPG is ok on this list, because it’s part platformer anyway. The first 2 paper mario games were much less so. At least what I can remember of them, before quitting because i was bored
April 9th, 2008 at 6:45 pm
I agree with Scott and say that my favorite has been Super Mario 64, but Super Mario Sunshine and Galaxy are also up there fighting for number 1! Those three are MY favorites, so deal with it!
April 9th, 2008 at 9:55 pm
Yoshi’s Island trumps all of these.
April 9th, 2008 at 11:07 pm
I would switch 64 and nsmb, but yeah, great list for my taste.
April 10th, 2008 at 12:05 am
I agree Mario 3 did the biggest evolution in terms of what Mario could do and how the rest of the games would be like. I definitely enjoyed SMW a ton though as it refined many of the things I liked about Mario 3 and polished it all to a blinding shine. It’s probably the only Mario game I can and will play over and over and over and not get sick of it.
Mario’s evolution to 3D (and the million clones and wannabes it spawned) is legendary and shouldn’t be forgotten though. It marked the first time a huge mascot jumped to the third dimension in proper fashion and was a ton of fun! I’m happy you guys included Sunshine despite the hate, I thought it was a fun change of pace and the backpack was actually pretty awesome, especially with the water-riding propeller.
Glad to see Mario RPG in there, further proof that Mario’s one of the few mascots that can go to so many genres and still be awesome. Which reminds me… Square, cough up the game for the VC!
April 10th, 2008 at 10:08 am
Great article. As for my two cents, I would still have to place Mario 64 at number one. Not only was the game a great adventure, but I have never experienced such a LEAP in gaming technology. Graphically and conceptually the game was ahead of its time and ushered in so many other 3D platformers for years to come.
As great as Mario 1, 3, and Galaxy were, they never delivered the same feeling as 64 did, and for that, I give it the number one slot.
April 11th, 2008 at 6:20 pm
@nintenmania:
Super Mario RPG is the best Mario RPG to date.
Unless Square Enix is involved with the next Paper Mario, it wouldn’t even compare to Super Mario RPG. It couldn’t even have Geno in it, since Square Enix was stubborn enough to insist that he remained a trademarked character.
Why the hell wasn’t Geno mentioned in the Super Mario RPG part, anyway? He’s the true main character in that game!
April 14th, 2008 at 7:20 am
super mario bros 3 was just too good. and its sales on the virtual console shows that most people agree.. the game was just perfect on so many levels…. super mario galaxy is 2nd cause its almost the same formula….. super mario world just doesnt match those two games even with yoshi.
April 14th, 2008 at 5:43 pm
i have all of those games. my fave is Super Mario 64.
April 15th, 2008 at 8:56 pm
great list. personally, i would have swapped SMB with SMB3 (always thought that one was overrated)
April 16th, 2008 at 10:13 am
SMW is still my favorite. SMB3 is everyone’s nostalgic vote, imho, but I prefer 2 to 3, but SMW was the quintessential refinement of all 2d platforming.
“It hasn’t been out long, but 15 minutes with Super Mario Galaxy is enough to prove its classic merit.”
Which is why it barely makes my top 5.
April 17th, 2008 at 7:35 pm
i like the list good job guys.
April 22nd, 2008 at 6:15 pm
Super Mario Galaxy!!!!!!!!!!!!! The best game for the Wii and the best Mario game.
April 29th, 2008 at 4:22 am
smb3 is the best hands down. smw is a fine game, but the cape makes it too easy (nearly limitless flight, nullify projectiles, etc.), and it is a poor substitute for the more imaginative powerups of smb3 (tanooki suit, kuribo’s shoe, frog suit, hammer bros. suit). the controls in smb3 are also absolutely perfect and it’s doubtful any game will ever approach that game’s ability to transform your will into what mario does on your screen.
smb3 is untouchable, the quintessence of video game.
May 19th, 2008 at 9:22 am
Paper mario is a great game! It should be number 3!But I tell ya. If super princess peach was on there, I’d scream!(and thats not a good thing!) And what about Mario kart DS?
Or smash brothers brawl?
May 21st, 2008 at 2:45 am
Any game that doesn’t have Mario in it. Is it just me, or does Mario give you the s**ts?
May 21st, 2008 at 11:47 pm
This is a masterful list.
May 22nd, 2008 at 9:05 am
New SMB and galaxy are my favourite besides Mario Kart ds…
May 22nd, 2008 at 9:11 pm
Yhea…..New SMB ROCKS!!
May 31st, 2008 at 9:08 pm
Smash brothers brawl is the BEST EVER!
June 7th, 2008 at 1:12 pm
Brawl is not a Mario game, Puppy. =P
June 16th, 2008 at 1:19 pm
Super Mario World would have to be my favourite, hands down. Not only was it my first video game, so I have fond memories, but after playing all of the others, it’s still the only one I can play over and over again endlessly without getting bored (as Liraco said).
June 19th, 2008 at 9:18 pm
SMB is a mario game. Well, sorta! Mario, peach, Bowser and luigi are all in it!You mean Hypersonic!
June 19th, 2008 at 9:19 pm
And do NOT call ME puppy, Hedgehog weirdo!
June 24th, 2008 at 12:57 pm
My top 10 are….
10:Paper Mario 2
9:Super Paper Mario
8:Mario world 2
7:Yoshi island
6:Mario cart DS
5:Mario galaxy
4:Mario bros.
3:Mario kart wii
2:New Mario bros.
1:Mario sunshine
June 24th, 2008 at 12:58 pm
My least favorite is Super princess peach. To short and easy.
June 24th, 2008 at 1:00 pm
Puppy gamer’s list……….Perfect!
June 24th, 2008 at 1:02 pm
Why did you name your self “Mario thingy”?
June 24th, 2008 at 1:04 pm
Why did you name your self Cheese wiz, Cheese head?!?!
June 24th, 2008 at 1:04 pm
Grrr….
June 24th, 2008 at 1:05 pm
THIS IS NOT A CHAT ROOM!
June 24th, 2008 at 1:06 pm
Especially not a chat room for yourself.
June 28th, 2008 at 1:53 pm
Mario Clash is the best Mario game evarrr
June 28th, 2008 at 6:40 pm
Wait, so is Yoshi’s Island not a “Proper Mario Platformer…?”
…i suppose not…
…but…but…Raphael the Raven…
June 28th, 2008 at 10:50 pm
1. Super Mario World
2. Super Mario 64
3. Super Mario Galaxy
4. New Super Mario Bros.
5. Super Mario Bros. 3
Anything else is BLASPHEMY.
June 29th, 2008 at 7:37 am
Blasfemy, craziness, all that.
June 30th, 2008 at 1:20 am
Best Mario game ever….Mario Clash on the Virtual Boy.
July 1st, 2008 at 1:29 pm
3 things
paper mario is a proper mario title
galaxy should have been #1
donkey kong should have made this list
July 3rd, 2008 at 12:36 pm
no problems with the list, except for the fact the rest of the games are missing. the list should be top 25 mario titles
August 1st, 2008 at 8:48 am
[...] Infendo offices have been buzzing with debate. It spilled over into last week??s edition of Infendohttp://www.infendo.com/nintendo/infendos-top-ten-mario-games/Disciples III: Renaissance - 5 New ScreensAdvances in gameplay and the addition of new elements will [...]